Nothwehr has spent the last four seasons at Lindsey Wilson College in Columbia, Ky., as the head men's and women's tennis coach and head volleyball coach.

Under Nothwehr's tutelage, the Blue Raider men's and women's tennis teams recorded a combined 100-30 record. She took the women's program from last in the Mid-South Conference to two NAIA National Tournament Semifinal finishes, while improving the men's team from 16th in the nation to eighth.

Named the Mid-South Conference Coach of the Year three times (2005, 2006, 2007), Nothwehr coached nine NAIA All-Americans and was a finalist for the NAIA Women's Tennis Coach of the Year in 2007.

Prior to Lindsey Wilson, Nothwehr served as an assistant coach in tennis and volleyball at Concordia (Nebraska) University, where she was a four-year letter winner in each sport as an undergraduate. Nothwehr was Great Plains Athletic Conference women's tennis player of the year in 2000 and was a first-team all-conference selection each of her four years. She was also a two-time NAIA Academic All-American in volleyball and received the team's "Most Inspirational Award" and "Most Dedicated" awards during her playing career.